Numerous momma-dos exist in the medical world, home remedies perse for specific injuries and such. However, many if not most of these methods are actually more dangerous than you would initially think. Everything from placing butter or shaving cream on burns to soaking in vinegar after a sun-burn. The methods are ludicrous, yet almost everyone can admit they have attempted to remedy an injury using one of the crazy first-aid standbys. After reading this article over at Reader’s Digest, you may not be saving lives, however, you will undoubtedly be improving the heal time for your next minor injury.
When the skin isn’t broken, it’s hard to beat iodine for killing bacteria. That’s why doctors use it to clean an area before surgery. But when there’s a cut, says dermatologist Robert Kirsner, a spokesperson for the American Academy of Dermatology, full-strength iodine, hydrogen peroxide and rubbing alcohol can be toxic to skin cells, impeding healing. The chemical reaction (and bubbling) that occurs when hydrogen peroxide hits the skin isn’t only cleaning the wound — it’s killing healthy cells. And that stinging from the rubbing alcohol? This stuff hurts because it’s wiping out healthy tissue.
Putting iodine on cuts and wounds kills bacteria, says VanRooyen, but it won’t clean the wound. “You want to protect the good tissue, and iodine doesn’t do that.” Mercurochrome also kills bacteria, but as the name suggests, it contains mercury, which is toxic, and not generally recognized as safe, says the FDA. Today, doctors don’t use Mercurochrome.
Better Bet
Remarkably, cleansing a wound has become much simpler: “The most effective way to get rid of debris and bacteria without damaging healthy tissue is flushing the wound out with water,” says VanRooyen. Put the wound under a faucet, or spray it with the nozzle on the kitchen sink. Flush it with water to clear it of all debris. If you are worried about the bandage sticking to the wound, consider using an antibacterial ointment that contains bacitracin or neomycin to keep the area lubricated.
[ed. note - looks like we got an article that looks very similar to one written in Reader's Digest a few years ago. My appologies. Please check out their article for all the details.]
3 Responses
moot
July 31st, 2006 at 2:36 pm
1You should be ashamed of yourself. This “article” is horrible. You obviously have no first aid experience and your research is pathetic. It is clear the only concern you have is ad money.
Drying a burn is the WORST suggestion i have ever heard on the subject. Butter, while not perfect for burns, works fine to keep the burn moist (which is the only help you can give burns - “dissapation of heat”! is idiotic to say the least). Butter even contains anti-bacterial agents (salt, and the extreme fat content), though there is no increased infection risk to any normal burn (assuming the skin is intact).
Dani Weber, DVM
July 31st, 2006 at 3:05 pm
2As a veterinarian, I have to say the Reader’s Digest article is spot on. I can’t tell you how many times I’ve dealt with delayed healing in a wound because the owner’s been pouring hydrogen peroxide in it.
The comment above by moot is completely inaccurate.
Justin
July 31st, 2006 at 3:12 pm
3Moot,
I appreciate your interest in the article. However, for the record, my medical knowledge is limited. I would like to point you to an organization that provides great material for research. Perhaps once you read the information, which provided some elements for this article, your opinions might change. That is if you’re not the type of person who believes the Center for Disease Control is part of some mass US conspiracy.
CDC Mass Casualties, Burn Information.
RSS feed for comments on this post · TrackBack URI
Leave a reply
Categories